I found this associated press article scrolling through my news feed this morning:
I have long since ignored my discovery from last November regarding Obama's Innovation Schools education reform plan as being just too bad to still be true. However, in this article Obama is quoted as saying "Charter schools that are successful will get the support they need to grow [...] And charters that aren't will get shut down. I want experimentation, but I also want accountability."
As I have previously stated, in 2005 Obama gave his, "Teaching Our Kids in a 21st Century Economy" speech in at the Center for American Progress in DC. See link below:
In this speech Obama details this aspect of his plan as:
So here’s what I’m proposing: the creation of what I call Innovation Districts. School districts from around the country that want to become seedbeds of reform would apply and we’d select the twenty with the best plans to put effective, supported teachers in all classrooms and increase achievement for all students. We’d offer these districts substantial new resources to do this, but in return, we’d ask them to try systemic new reforms. Above all, we’d require results.
[...]hold schools and teachers accountable for the results of all these reforms, Innovation Districts would be asked to support schools that succeed and shut down those that don’t.
So not only is he opening up schools to be shut down for participating in an "experiment," but his entire plan is volunatry. I can't imagine many schools would like to volunteer to be a guinea pig for the chance to have their school shut down. I agree this does enforce responsibility, but this gives no benefit for participation.
This is flat out a terrible plan and the one thing that everyday keeps me from writing a check to the Obama camp and keeps me hoping that McCain will somehow reasonably explain his 90% voting record to support President Bush.